![]() |
| Ten Commandments monument. Image source. |
Remember the Sabbath day by keeping it holy. Six days you shall labor and do all your work, but the seventh day is a sabbath to the Lord your God. On it you shall not do any work, neither you, nor your son or daughter, nor your male or female servant, nor your animals, nor any foreigner residing in your towns. For in six days the Lord made the heavens and the earth, the sea, and all that is in them, but he rested on the seventh day. Therefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day and made it holy.
---
If you read the 10 Commandments, you will find that one of them (I'm calling it the 4th, but Jewish and Christian traditions have numbered them in various different ways throughout history) says to "Remember the Sabbath day by keeping it holy." Elsewhere in the bible, there are additional details about this command to not work on the Sabbath. That's what it meant: don't work. (And then Jewish experts spent a lot of time discussing what exactly "work" means.)
In the church where I grew up, I never heard any teaching along the lines of "we should keep the Sabbath." I only knew that for Jewish people the Sabbath is Saturday, but Christians changed it to Sunday, because Jesus' resurrection was on a Sunday. And so we go to church on Sunday. But, uh, the bible doesn't say you "keep the Sabbath" by going to a religious gathering. Uh, that's not what it is at all. In the bible, the Sabbath is about not doing any work. Isn't it a bit weird that I never heard the suggestion that maybe as modern Christians *we* should not be doing any work on Sunday?
Occasionally there would be an article in a Christian magazine that said, "This professional athlete doesn't participate in games on Sundays, let's admire them for their great faith." And Chick-fil-A is closed on Sundays. But I never felt that anyone was saying "ALL of us should do that." Wait, was the point that people whose job has a Monday-to-Friday schedule are automatically keeping the Sabbath, and people whose job is structured differently than that and have to work on Sundays are not???? That doesn't seem fair at all. And in the bible when it says "don't work" it doesn't mean "don't go to your job"- it's much more wide-ranging than that. Lol, the idea that you could simply not go to your job, and that counts as "keeping the Sabbath." Tell me you've never heard about Orthodox Judaism without telling me.
When I was in college, I had some Christian friends who would do a Sabbath, which meant, they made sure to get all their homework done before Sunday, and then did not do any homework on Sunday. That was actually a big thing- most of us had a very high workload and were busy all the time, so it was actually pretty impressive to push all of the work onto different days and then have a whole entire day free.
But that was just their own personal practice; I never heard anyone make the claim that all Christians are supposed to be doing that. It was sort of an optional extra thing to do for God. I did it sometimes but not that much.
It's just so weird- and I noticed how weird this was back when I was evangelical too- that this is one of the 10 Commandments, and yet I've *never* heard a sermon telling us that we need to keep the Sabbath. I've never heard any Christians claiming "God commanded us to keep the Sabbath, so we are required to do that, and here are the exact rules about what counts as 'work.'"
And Christians use the 10 Commandments as a culture-war symbol all the time! There are court cases about how some Christian wants to put up a giant monument of the 10 Commandments on government property. There are conservative lawmakers telling schools they are required to put a poster of the 10 Commandments in every classroom. They claim that these laws are really important and everyone needs to be reminded of them- but have they actually read the 10 Commandments themselves? Do they keep the 10 Commandments? Do they care at all about the concept of Sabbath?
One argument that modern Christians might use- and very rarely does anyone care enough to actually make this argument- mostly the commandment to "keep the Sabbath" is completely ignored as if it's not even there- is that Jesus gave us a new interpretation of what Sabbath means. He had some run-ins with religious leaders who were unhappy that he wasn't keeping the Sabbath, and he told them, "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath."
Generally Christians interpret this to mean, the Pharisees were making all these little "legalistic" rules about what "keeping the Sabbath" meant. What exactly counts as "work." And all of it was really tedious and burdensome and totally misses the point. They even judged Jesus for healing people on the Sabbath. Seriously. Like keeping their weird arbitrary religious rules was more important than doing good and helping people.
And so, the thinking goes, Jesus invalidated the old teaching about the Sabbath, and gave us a new interpretation. What is the new interpretation? Uh... Basically we don't have to care about the Sabbath at all. Just go to church on Sundays, have vague positive feelings about the concept of work-life balance, and that's good enough. Lol, this is very much not how the bible tells us we should keep the Sabbath!
I do recognize that something seems wrong about a commandment telling us to "rest" being interpreted in a way that causes a lot of inconvenience. I like the way Jesus argued with the religious leaders and said, "The Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath." I can even get on board with the idea that we don't need to be so serious about defining what does or doesn't count as "work"; instead, the point is that it's not healthy for us to work all the time, and having free time is something we *should* prioritize. I can agree that we don't really need to "keep the Sabbath" in a strict way any more. (Maybe it made sense in the context of doing physically-intense farm work. And also, a big part of it was the requirement that you need to let your servants and slaves rest on the Sabbath.)
Okay, so, sure, I can agree that we don't really need to "keep the Sabbath." But. What I can't accept is the way that some Christians make such a big deal about following the bible, about following the 10 Commandments, posting the 10 Commandments in public schools, and then completely disregard the 4th commandment. If asked about it, they'll come up with some reason, like "Jesus' resurrection changed the Sabbath from Saturday to Sunday" or "the Pharisees were being legalistic about it" and therefore we can totally ignore this commandment- just some made-up justification, not found in the bible at all.
Wow, look at us, ignoring clear biblical commandments because we feel they don't really make sense for us. Have you ever realized that maybe people who follow other religions are doing that too? And non-religious people? It's fine for us to ignore the bible's teaching on the Sabbath (for pretty flimsy reasons), but apparently not fine for non-Christians to ignore the bible's teaching on everything else? Christians making such a big deal about how we have to get everyone to follow the bible- but we don't even follow the bible ourselves.
And then Christians make fun of Jewish people for taking the bible extremely seriously in a slightly different way than how we take the bible extremely seriously.
Anyway. Really weird how "keep the Sabbath" is one of the 10 Commandments, and yet I've never heard Christians teaching that we are required to do this. I've only heard of Christians making an individual commitment to keep the Sabbath, and we admire them for that, but we don't believe we're all supposed to be doing that. I hope you think about this whenever you hear about some politician trying to plaster the 10 Commandments all over government property.
---
Related
My Ex-Evangelical Take on "The Year of Living Biblically"
Inspiration and Incarnation: The Ten Commandments
And see also, this post from Hemant Mehta about James Talarico challenging the Texas bill requiring a poster of the Ten Commandments in every classroom: Texas voters oust Candy Noble, architect of the Ten Commandments in Classrooms law





